Redis中的LRU淘汰策略分析

Redis

Redis

• 惰性删除：每次从键空间中获取键时，都检查取得的键是否过期，如果过期的话，就删除该键；如果没有过期，就返回该键。
• 定期删除：每隔一段时间，程序就对数据库进行一次检查，删除里面的过期键。

另外，

Redis

LRU

LRU算法

当需要从缓存中淘汰数据时，我们希望能淘汰那些将来不可能再被使用的数据，保留那些将来还会频繁访问的数据，但最大的问题是缓存并不能预言未来。一个解决方法就是通过

LRU

举例如下的访问模式，A每5s访问一次，B每2s访问一次，C与D每10s访问一次，

|

~~~~~A~~~~~A~~~~~A~~~~A~~~~~A~~~~~A~~|
~~B~~B~~B~~B~~B~~B~~B~~B~~B~~B~~B~~B~|
~~~~~~~~~~C~~~~~~~~~C~~~~~~~~~C~~~~~~|
~~~~~D~~~~~~~~~~D~~~~~~~~~D~~~~~~~~~D|

可以看到，

LRU

但是，总体来说，

LRU

LRU配置参数

Redis

LRU

• maxmemory

  : 配置

  Redis

  存储数据时指定限制的内存大小，比如

  100m

  。当缓存消耗的内存超过这个数值时, 将触发数据淘汰。该数据配置为0时，表示缓存的数据量没有限制, 即LRU功能不生效。64位的系统默认值为0，32位的系统默认内存限制为3GB

• maxmemory_policy

  : 触发数据淘汰后的淘汰策略

• maxmemory_samples

  : 随机采样的精度，也就是随即取出key的数目。该数值配置越大, 越接近于真实的LRU算法，但是数值越大，相应消耗也变高，对性能有一定影响，样本值默认为5。

淘汰策略

淘汰策略即

maxmemory_policy

• noeviction

  :如果缓存数据超过了

  maxmemory

  限定值，并且客户端正在执行的命令(大部分的写入指令，但DEL和几个指令例外)会导致内存分配，则向客户端返回错误响应

• allkeys-lru

  : 对所有的键都采取

  LRU

  淘汰

• volatile-lru

  : 仅对设置了过期时间的键采取

  LRU

  淘汰

• allkeys-random

  : 随机回收所有的键

• volatile-random

  : 随机回收设置过期时间的键

• volatile-ttl

  : 仅淘汰设置了过期时间的键---淘汰生存时间

  TTL(Time To Live)

  更小的键

volatile-lru

volatile-random

volatile-ttl

noeviction

一般的经验规则:

• 使用

  allkeys-lru

  策略：当预期请求符合一个幂次分布(二八法则等)，比如一部分的子集元素比其它其它元素被访问的更多时，可以选择这个策略。
• 使用

  allkeys-random

  ：循环连续的访问所有的键时，或者预期请求分布平均（所有元素被访问的概率都差不多）
• 使用

  volatile-ttl

  ：要采取这个策略，缓存对象的

  TTL

  值最好有差异

volatile-lru

volatile-random

Redis

为键设置过期时间也是需要消耗内存的，所以使用

allkeys-lru

近似LRU算法

我们知道，

LRU

Redis

LRU

Redis

LRU

maxmemory-samples

根据

Redis

Redis Object

Redis Object

unix time

LRU clock

Redis

Redis

N个key

Redis

pool

pool

pool

真实

LRU

LRU

浅灰色带是已经被淘汰的对象，灰色带是没有被淘汰的对象，绿色带是新添加的对象。可以看出，

maxmemory-samples

Redis 3.0

Redis 2.8

Redis 3.0

LRU

数据访问模式非常接近幂次分布时，也就是大部分的访问集中于部分键时，

LRU

在模拟实验的过程中，我们发现如果使用幂次分布的访问模式，真实

LRU

LRU

LRU源码分析

Redis

redisObject

typedef struct redisObject {
unsigned type:4;
unsigned encoding:4;
unsigned lru:LRU_BITS; /* LRU time (relative to global lru_clock) or
* LFU data (least significant 8 bits frequency
* and most significant 16 bits access time). */
int refcount;
void *ptr;
} robj;

unsigned

lru

redisObj

Redis命令访问缓存的数据时,均会调用函数

lookupKey

robj *lookupKey(redisDb *db, robj *key, int flags) {
dictEntry *de = dictFind(db->dict,key->ptr);
if (de) {
robj *val = dictGetVal(de);

/* Update the access time for the ageing algorithm.
* Don't do it if we have a saving child, as this will trigger
* a copy on write madness. */
if (server.rdb_child_pid == -1 &&
server.aof_child_pid == -1 &&
!(flags & LOOKUP_NOTOUCH))
{
if (server.maxmemory_policy & MAXMEMORY_FLAG_LFU) {
updateLFU(val);
} else {
val->lru = LRU_CLOCK();
}
}
return val;
} else {
return NULL;
}
}

该函数在策略为

LRU(非LFU)

lru

LRU_CLOCK()

/* Return the LRU clock, based on the clock resolution. This is a time
* in a reduced-bits format that can be used to set and check the
* object->lru field of redisObject structures. */
unsigned int getLRUClock(void) {
return (mstime()/LRU_CLOCK_RESOLUTION) & LRU_CLOCK_MAX;
}

/* This function is used to obtain the current LRU clock.
* If the current resolution is lower than the frequency we refresh the
* LRU clock (as it should be in production servers) we return the
* precomputed value, otherwise we need to resort to a system call. */
unsigned int LRU_CLOCK(void) {
unsigned int lruclock;
if (1000/server.hz <= LRU_CLOCK_RESOLUTION) {
atomicGet(server.lruclock,lruclock);
} else {
lruclock = getLRUClock();
}
return lruclock;
}

LRU_CLOCK()

LRU_CLOCK_RESOLUTION(默认值1000)

LRU_CLOCK_RESOLUTION

LRU

LRU

server.hz

LRU

LRU_CLOCK()

Redis

processCommand

int processCommand(client *c) {

/* Handle the maxmemory directive.
*
* Note that we do not want to reclaim memory if we are here re-entering
* the event loop since there is a busy Lua script running in timeout
* condition, to avoid mixing the propagation of scripts with the
* propagation of DELs due to eviction. */
if (server.maxmemory && !server.lua_timedout) {
int out_of_memory = freeMemoryIfNeededAndSafe() == C_ERR;
/* freeMemoryIfNeeded may flush slave output buffers. This may result
* into a slave, that may be the active client, to be freed. */
if (server.current_client == NULL) return C_ERR;

/* It was impossible to free enough memory, and the command the client
* is trying to execute is denied during OOM conditions or the client
* is in MULTI/EXEC context? Error. */
if (out_of_memory &&
(c->cmd->flags & CMD_DENYOOM ||
(c->flags & CLIENT_MULTI && c->cmd->proc != execCommand))) {
flagTransaction(c);
addReply(c, shared.oomerr);
return C_OK;
}
}
}

只列出了释放内存空间的部分，

freeMemoryIfNeededAndSafe

int freeMemoryIfNeeded(void) {
/* By default replicas should ignore maxmemory
* and just be masters exact copies. */
if (server.masterhost && server.repl_slave_ignore_maxmemory) return C_OK;

size_t mem_reported, mem_tofree, mem_freed;
mstime_t latency, eviction_latency;
long long delta;
int slaves = listLength(server.slaves);

/* When clients are paused the dataset should be static not just from the
* POV of clients not being able to write, but also from the POV of
* expires and evictions of keys not being performed. */
if (clientsArePaused()) return C_OK;
if (getMaxmemoryState(&mem_reported,NULL,&mem_tofree,NULL) == C_OK)
return C_OK;

mem_freed = 0;

if (server.maxmemory_policy == MAXMEMORY_NO_EVICTION)
goto cant_free; /* We need to free memory, but policy forbids. */

latencyStartMonitor(latency);
while (mem_freed < mem_tofree) {
int j, k, i, keys_freed = 0;
static unsigned int next_db = 0;
sds bestkey = NULL;
int bestdbid;
redisDb *db;
dict *dict;
dictEntry *de;

if (server.maxmemory_policy & (MAXMEMORY_FLAG_LRU|MAXMEMORY_FLAG_LFU) ||
server.maxmemory_policy == MAXMEMORY_VOLATILE_TTL)
{
struct evictionPoolEntry *pool = EvictionPoolLRU;

while(bestkey == NULL) {
unsigned long total_keys = 0, keys;

/* We don't want to make local-db choices when expiring keys,
* so to start populate the eviction pool sampling keys from
* every DB. */
for (i = 0; i < server.dbnum; i++) {
db = server.db+i;
dict = (server.maxmemory_policy & MAXMEMORY_FLAG_ALLKEYS) ?
db->dict : db->expires;
if ((keys = dictSize(dict)) != 0) {
evictionPoolPopulate(i, dict, db->dict, pool);
total_keys += keys;
}
}
if (!total_keys) break; /* No keys to evict. */

/* Go backward from best to worst element to evict. */
for (k = EVPOOL_SIZE-1; k >= 0; k--) {
if (pool[k].key == NULL) continue;
bestdbid = pool[k].dbid;

if (server.maxmemory_policy & MAXMEMORY_FLAG_ALLKEYS) {
de = dictFind(server.db[pool[k].dbid].dict,
pool[k].key);
} else {
de = dictFind(server.db[pool[k].dbid].expires,
pool[k].key);
}

/* Remove the entry from the pool. */
if (pool[k].key != pool[k].cached)
sdsfree(pool[k].key);
pool[k].key = NULL;
pool[k].idle = 0;

/* If the key exists, is our pick. Otherwise it is
* a ghost and we need to try the next element. */
if (de) {
bestkey = dictGetKey(de);
break;
} else {
/* Ghost... Iterate again. */
}
}
}
}

/* volatile-random and allkeys-random policy */
else if (server.maxmemory_policy == MAXMEMORY_ALLKEYS_RANDOM ||
server.maxmemory_policy == MAXMEMORY_VOLATILE_RANDOM)
{
/* When evicting a random key, we try to evict a key for
* each DB, so we use the static 'next_db' variable to
* incrementally visit all DBs. */
for (i = 0; i < server.dbnum; i++) {
j = (++next_db) % server.dbnum;
db = server.db+j;
dict = (server.maxmemory_policy == MAXMEMORY_ALLKEYS_RANDOM) ?
db->dict : db->expires;
if (dictSize(dict) != 0) {
de = dictGetRandomKey(dict);
bestkey = dictGetKey(de);
bestdbid = j;
break;
}
}
}

/* Finally remove the selected key. */
if (bestkey) {
db = server.db+bestdbid;
robj *keyobj = createStringObject(bestkey,sdslen(bestkey));
propagateExpire(db,keyobj,server.lazyfree_lazy_eviction);
/* We compute the amount of memory freed by db*Delete() alone.
* It is possible that actually the memory needed to propagate
* the DEL in AOF and replication link is greater than the one
* we are freeing removing the key, but we can't account for
* that otherwise we would never exit the loop.
*
* AOF and Output buffer memory will be freed eventually so
* we only care about memory used by the key space. */
delta = (long long) zmalloc_used_memory();
latencyStartMonitor(eviction_latency);
if (server.lazyfree_lazy_eviction)
dbAsyncDelete(db,keyobj);
else
dbSyncDelete(db,keyobj);
latencyEndMonitor(eviction_latency);
latencyAddSampleIfNeeded("eviction-del",eviction_latency);
latencyRemoveNestedEvent(latency,eviction_latency);
delta -= (long long) zmalloc_used_memory();
mem_freed += delta;
server.stat_evictedkeys++;
notifyKeyspaceEvent(NOTIFY_EVICTED, "evicted",
keyobj, db->id);
decrRefCount(keyobj);
keys_freed++;

/* When the memory to free starts to be big enough, we may
* start spending so much time here that is impossible to
* deliver data to the slaves fast enough, so we force the
* transmission here inside the loop. */
if (slaves) flushSlavesOutputBuffers();

/* Normally our stop condition is the ability to release
* a fixed, pre-computed amount of memory. However when we
* are deleting objects in another thread, it's better to
* check, from time to time, if we already reached our target
* memory, since the "mem_freed" amount is computed only
* across the dbAsyncDelete() call, while the thread can
* release the memory all the time. */
if (server.lazyfree_lazy_eviction && !(keys_freed % 16)) {
if (getMaxmemoryState(NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL) == C_OK) {
/* Let's satisfy our stop condition. */
mem_freed = mem_tofree;
}
}
}

if (!keys_freed) {
latencyEndMonitor(latency);
latencyAddSampleIfNeeded("eviction-cycle",latency);
goto cant_free; /* nothing to free... */
}
}
latencyEndMonitor(latency);
latencyAddSampleIfNeeded("eviction-cycle",latency);
return C_OK;

cant_free:
/* We are here if we are not able to reclaim memory. There is only one
* last thing we can try: check if the lazyfree thread has jobs in queue
* and wait... */
while(bioPendingJobsOfType(BIO_LAZY_FREE)) {
if (((mem_reported - zmalloc_used_memory()) + mem_freed) >= mem_tofree)
break;
usleep(1000);
}
return C_ERR;
}

/* This is a wrapper for freeMemoryIfNeeded() that only really calls the
* function if right now there are the conditions to do so safely:
*
* - There must be no script in timeout condition.
* - Nor we are loading data right now.
*
*/
int freeMemoryIfNeededAndSafe(void) {
if (server.lua_timedout || server.loading) return C_OK;
return freeMemoryIfNeeded();
}

几种淘汰策略

maxmemory_policy

当采用

LRU

redisDb

dict(全部键)

expires(有过期时间的键)

pool

pool

evictionPoolPopulate

void evictionPoolPopulate(int dbid, dict *sampledict, dict *keydict, struct evictionPoolEntry *pool) {
int j, k, count;
dictEntry *samples[server.maxmemory_samples];

count = dictGetSomeKeys(sampledict,samples,server.maxmemory_samples);
for (j = 0; j < count; j++) {
unsigned long long idle;
sds key;
robj *o;
dictEntry *de;

de = samples[j];
key = dictGetKey(de);

/* If the dictionary we are sampling from is not the main
* dictionary (but the expires one) we need to lookup the key
* again in the key dictionary to obtain the value object. */
if (server.maxmemory_policy != MAXMEMORY_VOLATILE_TTL) {
if (sampledict != keydict) de = dictFind(keydict, key);
o = dictGetVal(de);
}

/* Calculate the idle time according to the policy. This is called
* idle just because the code initially handled LRU, but is in fact
* just a score where an higher score means better candidate. */
if (server.maxmemory_policy & MAXMEMORY_FLAG_LRU) {
idle = estimateObjectIdleTime(o);
} else if (server.maxmemory_policy & MAXMEMORY_FLAG_LFU) {
/* When we use an LRU policy, we sort the keys by idle time
* so that we expire keys starting from greater idle time.
* However when the policy is an LFU one, we have a frequency
* estimation, and we want to evict keys with lower frequency
* first. So inside the pool we put objects using the inverted
* frequency subtracting the actual frequency to the maximum
* frequency of 255. */
idle = 255-LFUDecrAndReturn(o);
} else if (server.maxmemory_policy == MAXMEMORY_VOLATILE_TTL) {
/* In this case the sooner the expire the better. */
idle = ULLONG_MAX - (long)dictGetVal(de);
} else {
serverPanic("Unknown eviction policy in evictionPoolPopulate()");
}

/* Insert the element inside the pool.
* First, find the first empty bucket or the first populated
* bucket that has an idle time smaller than our idle time. */
k = 0;
while (k < EVPOOL_SIZE &&
pool[k].key &&
pool[k].idle < idle) k++;
if (k == 0 && pool[EVPOOL_SIZE-1].key != NULL) {
/* Can't insert if the element is < the worst element we have
* and there are no empty buckets. */
continue;
} else if (k < EVPOOL_SIZE && pool[k].key == NULL) {
/* Inserting into empty position. No setup needed before insert. */
} else {
/* Inserting in the middle. Now k points to the first element
* greater than the element to insert.  */
if (pool[EVPOOL_SIZE-1].key == NULL) {
/* Free space on the right? Insert at k shifting
* all the elements from k to end to the right. */

/* Save SDS before overwriting. */
sds cached = pool[EVPOOL_SIZE-1].cached;
memmove(pool+k+1,pool+k,
sizeof(pool[0])*(EVPOOL_SIZE-k-1));
pool[k].cached = cached;
} else {
/* No free space on right? Insert at k-1 */
k--;
/* Shift all elements on the left of k (included) to the
* left, so we discard the element with smaller idle time. */
sds cached = pool[0].cached; /* Save SDS before overwriting. */
if (pool[0].key != pool[0].cached) sdsfree(pool[0].key);
memmove(pool,pool+1,sizeof(pool[0])*k);
pool[k].cached = cached;
}
}

/* Try to reuse the cached SDS string allocated in the pool entry,
* because allocating and deallocating this object is costly
* (according to the profiler, not my fantasy. Remember:
* premature optimizbla bla bla bla. */
int klen = sdslen(key);
if (klen > EVPOOL_CACHED_SDS_SIZE) {
pool[k].key = sdsdup(key);
} else {
memcpy(pool[k].cached,key,klen+1);
sdssetlen(pool[k].cached,klen);
pool[k].key = pool[k].cached;
}
pool[k].idle = idle;
pool[k].dbid = dbid;
}
}

Redis

maxmemory_samples

idle time

estimateObjectIdleTime

Redis

/* Given an object returns the min number of milliseconds the object was never
* requested, using an approximated LRU algorithm. */
unsigned long long estimateObjectIdleTime(robj *o) {
unsigned long long lruclock = LRU_CLOCK();
if (lruclock >= o->lru) {
return (lruclock - o->lru) * LRU_CLOCK_RESOLUTION;
} else {
return (lruclock + (LRU_CLOCK_MAX - o->lru)) *
LRU_CLOCK_RESOLUTION;
}
}

空闲时间基本就是就是对象的

lru

LRU_CLOCK()

LRU_CLOCK_RESOLUTION

参考链接

• Random notes on improving the Redis LRU algorithm
• Using Redis as an LRU cache